Curtas do Bryant´s

USN – UK warship disarms suspected pirates

The US Navy issued a news release stating that a Royal Navy frigate, while operating as part of Combined Task Force (CTF) 151, detected, intercepted, and boarded two suspicious skiffs in the Gulf of Aden. The skiffs carried grappling hooks and a cache of weapons. The weapons were confiscated and one skiff was destroyed (was it on a manifestly unsafe voyage?). Because the individuals could not be linked to a specific piratical attack, they were released. (6/2/09).

Fear-of-cancer jury instruction in FELA asbestosis case

The US Supreme Court ruled that, upon request of the defendant, a trial court must give the jury a fear-of-cancer instruction in an asbestosis case brought under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA). In the instant case, plaintiff employee brought suit against defendant railroad alleging that the railroad’s negligence caused him to contract asbestosis. He also sought pain-and-suffering damages based on, among other things, his fear of developing lung cancer in the future. At trial, defendant sought an instruction to the jury that plaintiff had to prove that his alleged fear was genuine and serious. This proposed jury instruction was based on a footnote in an earlier Supreme Court decision in a FELA asbestosis case. Without hearing oral argument, the Court in the instant case, issued a per curium decision holding that the trial court should have given the substance of the requested instruction. The case was remanded for further proceedings. There were two dissenting opinions filed in this case. CSX Transportation, Inc. v. Thurston, No. 08-1034 (June 1, 2009). Note: This decision is of moment to the maritime community because liability for personal injury under the Jones Act is based on the standards of the FELA. Fonte: Dennis Bryant.